616 Cotterill Road • Gibson Island, MD 21056

$3,595,000 Beds: 6 • Baths: 5 full 2 partial • Sq. Feet: 7498 • MLS ID: MDAA2136408 • Subdivision: GIBSON ISLAND • School Dist: ANNE ARUNDEL COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
Perfectly located in the heart of Gibson Island, this exquisite American Craftsman residence offers timeless architectural character and tranquil views overlooking Otter Pond. A stone walkway winds through mature landscaping to a striking covered entry, where a handcrafted wood front door, lantern-style gas lit sconces, and exposed wood eaves introduce the home’s thoughtful design and refined craftsmanship. Originally built in 1930, this property was comprehensively rebuilt and expanded in 2023 by the current owners. Designed by architect Bryian Swanson, Swanson Design, and constructed by acclaimed builder Delbert Adams, the home blends classic, high-quality Craftsman elements—textured stucco, copper gutters, architectural shingles, deep overhangs with natural wood detailing, custom mahogany vaulted ceilings and front hall cabinetry, and custom Andersen windows—with modern enhancements. Throughout the home, tranquil pond and woodland vistas reinforce a sense of privacy and connection to nature. Both welcoming and secluded, the setting captures the essence of Gibson Island living--architectural integrity, natural beauty, and year-round appeal. With an interior footprint of 6,348 square feet above grade and a 1,150-square-foot finished basement, the floor plan includes six bedrooms, five full baths, and two half baths across three finished levels. A chef’s gourmet kitchen designed by renowned kitchen designer, Jennifer Gilmore, is at the heart of the home. The house includes a breakfast room, living room, “pond room,” den, and stunning wet bar. The private, wooded property spans 1.1 acres, is thoughtfully landscaped and has an irrigation system for the upper lawn and garden areas. The property conveys with a separate 3,225-square-foot waterfront lot off Stillwater Road below the house, ensuring permanent views and direct access to Otter Pond. If a dock is to be built there, it must be approved by the Gibson Island Corporation Architectural Committee, the Gibson Island Corporation, and Anne Arundel County, and other governmental entities. More information on this may take additional time. The grounds are thoughtfully landscaped. Information on Gibson Island: Gibson Island is a private island within one hour of Washington, D.C. and Baltimore offering an absolutely extraordinary setting. The Island comprises 1000 acres with seven miles of shoreline. Two thirds of the Island is undeveloped and is owned by the Gibson Island Corporation, the homeowners' association. The remaining third is residential home sites. Gibson Island is located on the western shore of Maryland, so there is no need to cross the Bay Bridge. On the Island is a 43-acre spring fed freshwater lake in which one may enjoy non-motorized watercraft activities such as paddleboarding, canoeing, kayaking, fishing and swimming. The Island offers enormous privacy and security--there is an entry gatehouse staffed 24+Hours, and the Island is patrolled by the Gibson Island Police Force (GIPD). The Gibson Island Corporation Service Department offers yard maintenance and landscaping and other services for homeowners. There is a full-service yacht yard. From the Island, it is just a 20-minute drive to BWI Airport and the neighboring Amtrak train station. The Island houses a private country club (membership by invitation) offering yachting, fine dining year-round, tennis, an award-winning Charles Blair Macdonald designed 9-hole golf course, swimming, croquet, skeet shooting, and more. (C) View this listing at: http://countonrick.com/mls=MDAA2136408

Property Features

  • Taxes: $31,904
  • Basement: Yes
  • Wooded: Yes
  • Roof Type: Architectural Shingle
  • Exterior: Stucco
  • Special View Info: Pond,Street,Trees/Woods,Garden/Lawn
  • Lot Size: 1.11 Acres
  • Lot Dimensions: 1.11 Acre(S)
  • Heating: Programmable Thermostat,Zoned
  • Fuel Type: Propane - Owned
  • Cooling: Central A/C,Ceiling Fan(s),Programmable Thermostat
  • Year Built: 1930
  • Fireplaces: 4
  • Water: Public
  • Sewer: Private Septic Tank
  • Stories: 3.0
  • HOA Fee: $1478.00/Monthly
  • Additional Structures: Above Grade,Below Grade
  • Location Description: Corner Lot/Unit
  • Lot Description: Additional Lot(s), Corner, Front Yard, Landlocked, Landscaping, Pond, Premium, SideYard(s), Sloping, Trees/Wooded
  • Structure Type: Detached
  • Parking Features: Circular Driveway,Gravel Driveway
  • Appliances: Refrigerator,Water Heater - Tankless,Built-In Microwave,Dishwasher,Dryer,Exhaust Fan,Instant Hot Water,Microwave,Oven/Range - Gas,Range Hood,Washer,Water Heater - High-Efficiency,Oven - Wall,Stainless Steel Appliances
  • Rooms: Living Room,Dining Room,Primary Bedroom,Sitting Room,Bedroom 2,Bedroom 3,Bedroom 4,Bedroom 5,Kitchen,Family Room,Foyer,Breakfast Room,Laundry,Office,Recreation Room,Storage Room,Utility Room,Bedroom 6,Bathroom 2,Bathroom 3,Bonus Room,Primary Bathroom,Full Bath,Half Bath
  • Basement: Connecting Stairway,Daylight, Full,Full,Fully Finished,Improved,Interior Access,Partially Finished,Side Entrance,Walkout Level,Windows,Other
  • Lake Name: Otter Lake
  • Community Amenities: Beach,Bike Trail,Common Grounds,Gated Community,Jog/Walk Path,Lake,Picnic Area,Pier/Dock,Security,Other
  • SQFT Total Finished: 7498
  • SQFT Above Finished: 6348
  • SQFT Below Finished: 1150
  • Exterior: Extensive Hardscape,Exterior Lighting,Gutter System
  • Interior: Bathroom - Soaking Tub,Bathroom - Walk-In Shower,Built-Ins,Ceiling Fan(s),Entry Level Bedroom,Exposed Beams,Floor Plan - Traditional,Kitchen - Gourmet,Kitchen - Island,Primary Bath(s),Upgraded Countertops,Walk-in Closet(s),Wet/Dry Bar,Attic,Breakfast Area,Formal/Separate Dining Room,Recessed Lighting,Sound System,Sprinkler System,Window Treatments,Wine Storage,Dining Area,Store/Office,Wainscotting,Wood Floors
  • Fireplace: Wood,Gas/Propane,Mantel(s),Double Sided
  • Flooring: Stone,Ceramic Tile,Heated,Hardwood
  • Windows: Screens,Casement
  • Utilities: Electric Available,Water Available

School Information

  • High School: CHESAPEAKE
  • Middle School: CHESAPEAKE BAY
  • Elementary School: BODKIN
  • School District: ANNE ARUNDEL COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
Printed March 04, 2026


Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 03/04/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 03/04/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Wed 03/04/2026 12:04:59 AM EST) or Bright MLS (last updated Tue 03/03/2026 11:58:15 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility
Federal Housing Equal Opportunity Realtor
Corporate Office - 215 S Centerville Rd. Lancaster, PA 17603
James J Hafer - West Virginia Broker of Record

©2026 BHH Affiliates, LLC. An independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC. Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices symbol are registered service marks of Columbia Insurance Company, a Berkshire Hathaway affiliate. Equal Housing Opportunity.


Agent License Information: 
Licensed in Pennsylvania
The Rick Shaffer Team
Rickey Shaffer, Travis Shaffer, Austin Shaffer, Richard Vangel, Amanda Croumer, Alexis Moore  

1680 Kenneth Road, York, PA 17408
717-757-7811